prometheus query return 0 if no data

Timestamps here can be explicit or implicit. Why is this sentence from The Great Gatsby grammatical? While the sample_limit patch stops individual scrapes from using too much Prometheus capacity, which could lead to creating too many time series in total and exhausting total Prometheus capacity (enforced by the first patch), which would in turn affect all other scrapes since some new time series would have to be ignored. Can I tell police to wait and call a lawyer when served with a search warrant? In this blog post well cover some of the issues one might encounter when trying to collect many millions of time series per Prometheus instance. and can help you on This single sample (data point) will create a time series instance that will stay in memory for over two and a half hours using resources, just so that we have a single timestamp & value pair. As we mentioned before a time series is generated from metrics. Heres a screenshot that shows exact numbers: Thats an average of around 5 million time series per instance, but in reality we have a mixture of very tiny and very large instances, with the biggest instances storing around 30 million time series each. At this point we should know a few things about Prometheus: With all of that in mind we can now see the problem - a metric with high cardinality, especially one with label values that come from the outside world, can easily create a huge number of time series in a very short time, causing cardinality explosion. what does the Query Inspector show for the query you have a problem with? This is optional, but may be useful if you don't already have an APM, or would like to use our templates and sample queries. Separate metrics for total and failure will work as expected. I'm not sure what you mean by exposing a metric. Although, sometimes the values for project_id doesn't exist, but still end up showing up as one. Will this approach record 0 durations on every success? The main reason why we prefer graceful degradation is that we want our engineers to be able to deploy applications and their metrics with confidence without being subject matter experts in Prometheus. I'm sure there's a proper way to do this, but in the end, I used label_replace to add an arbitrary key-value label to each sub-query that I wished to add to the original values, and then applied an or to each. Each Prometheus is scraping a few hundred different applications, each running on a few hundred servers. I am always registering the metric as defined (in the Go client library) by prometheus.MustRegister(). A sample is something in between metric and time series - its a time series value for a specific timestamp. One of the most important layers of protection is a set of patches we maintain on top of Prometheus. See this article for details. This is because the Prometheus server itself is responsible for timestamps. For Prometheus to collect this metric we need our application to run an HTTP server and expose our metrics there. Bulk update symbol size units from mm to map units in rule-based symbology. If you're looking for a @zerthimon You might want to use 'bool' with your comparator The problem is that the table is also showing reasons that happened 0 times in the time frame and I don't want to display them. - grafana-7.1.0-beta2.windows-amd64, how did you install it? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. If such a stack trace ended up as a label value it would take a lot more memory than other time series, potentially even megabytes. Basically our labels hash is used as a primary key inside TSDB. Run the following command on the master node: Once the command runs successfully, youll see joining instructions to add the worker node to the cluster. notification_sender-. Browse other questions tagged, Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide. You can calculate how much memory is needed for your time series by running this query on your Prometheus server: Note that your Prometheus server must be configured to scrape itself for this to work. more difficult for those people to help. A common class of mistakes is to have an error label on your metrics and pass raw error objects as values. To get a better understanding of the impact of a short lived time series on memory usage lets take a look at another example. This is the standard Prometheus flow for a scrape that has the sample_limit option set: The entire scrape either succeeds or fails. Select the query and do + 0. Perhaps I misunderstood, but it looks like any defined metrics that hasn't yet recorded any values can be used in a larger expression. Its also worth mentioning that without our TSDB total limit patch we could keep adding new scrapes to Prometheus and that alone could lead to exhausting all available capacity, even if each scrape had sample_limit set and scraped fewer time series than this limit allows. The number of time series depends purely on the number of labels and the number of all possible values these labels can take. 02:00 - create a new chunk for 02:00 - 03:59 time range, 04:00 - create a new chunk for 04:00 - 05:59 time range, 22:00 - create a new chunk for 22:00 - 23:59 time range. Secondly this calculation is based on all memory used by Prometheus, not only time series data, so its just an approximation. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. The only exception are memory-mapped chunks which are offloaded to disk, but will be read into memory if needed by queries. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. A time series is an instance of that metric, with a unique combination of all the dimensions (labels), plus a series of timestamp & value pairs - hence the name time series. Creating new time series on the other hand is a lot more expensive - we need to allocate new memSeries instances with a copy of all labels and keep it in memory for at least an hour. If the time series doesnt exist yet and our append would create it (a new memSeries instance would be created) then we skip this sample. By clicking Sign up for GitHub, you agree to our terms of service and Our patched logic will then check if the sample were about to append belongs to a time series thats already stored inside TSDB or is it a new time series that needs to be created. Once we do that we need to pass label values (in the same order as label names were specified) when incrementing our counter to pass this extra information. rev2023.3.3.43278. Is it suspicious or odd to stand by the gate of a GA airport watching the planes? To select all HTTP status codes except 4xx ones, you could run: http_requests_total {status!~"4.."} Subquery Return the 5-minute rate of the http_requests_total metric for the past 30 minutes, with a resolution of 1 minute. what error message are you getting to show that theres a problem? If this query also returns a positive value, then our cluster has overcommitted the memory. information which you think might be helpful for someone else to understand help customers build Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. website I've added a data source (prometheus) in Grafana. Since we know that the more labels we have the more time series we end up with, you can see when this can become a problem. This holds true for a lot of labels that we see are being used by engineers. bay, Is a PhD visitor considered as a visiting scholar? How do I align things in the following tabular environment? Our metric will have a single label that stores the request path. This works well if errors that need to be handled are generic, for example Permission Denied: But if the error string contains some task specific information, for example the name of the file that our application didnt have access to, or a TCP connection error, then we might easily end up with high cardinality metrics this way: Once scraped all those time series will stay in memory for a minimum of one hour. Having good internal documentation that covers all of the basics specific for our environment and most common tasks is very important. I.e., there's no way to coerce no datapoints to 0 (zero)? On the worker node, run the kubeadm joining command shown in the last step. Even i am facing the same issue Please help me on this. want to sum over the rate of all instances, so we get fewer output time series, This is true both for client libraries and Prometheus server, but its more of an issue for Prometheus itself, since a single Prometheus server usually collects metrics from many applications, while an application only keeps its own metrics. Stumbled onto this post for something else unrelated, just was +1-ing this :). Thirdly Prometheus is written in Golang which is a language with garbage collection. In Prometheus pulling data is done via PromQL queries and in this article we guide the reader through 11 examples that can be used for Kubernetes specifically. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. 2023 The Linux Foundation. rev2023.3.3.43278. Especially when dealing with big applications maintained in part by multiple different teams, each exporting some metrics from their part of the stack. For operations between two instant vectors, the matching behavior can be modified. "no data". We can use these to add more information to our metrics so that we can better understand whats going on. Both patches give us two levels of protection. privacy statement. gabrigrec September 8, 2021, 8:12am #8. The main motivation seems to be that dealing with partially scraped metrics is difficult and youre better off treating failed scrapes as incidents. hackers at This is what i can see on Query Inspector. I believe it's the logic that it's written, but is there any . If so I'll need to figure out a way to pre-initialize the metric which may be difficult since the label values may not be known a priori. Are there tables of wastage rates for different fruit and veg? What this means is that using Prometheus defaults each memSeries should have a single chunk with 120 samples on it for every two hours of data. will get matched and propagated to the output. You can query Prometheus metrics directly with its own query language: PromQL. You can verify this by running the kubectl get nodes command on the master node. Since labels are copied around when Prometheus is handling queries this could cause significant memory usage increase. source, what your query is, what the query inspector shows, and any other Going back to our time series - at this point Prometheus either creates a new memSeries instance or uses already existing memSeries. The simplest construct of a PromQL query is an instant vector selector. vishnur5217 May 31, 2020, 3:44am 1. Looking to learn more? Each time series stored inside Prometheus (as a memSeries instance) consists of: The amount of memory needed for labels will depend on the number and length of these. Cardinality is the number of unique combinations of all labels. The reason why we still allow appends for some samples even after were above sample_limit is that appending samples to existing time series is cheap, its just adding an extra timestamp & value pair. Thats why what our application exports isnt really metrics or time series - its samples. Minimising the environmental effects of my dyson brain. For example, if someone wants to modify sample_limit, lets say by changing existing limit of 500 to 2,000, for a scrape with 10 targets, thats an increase of 1,500 per target, with 10 targets thats 10*1,500=15,000 extra time series that might be scraped. t]. The number of times some specific event occurred. Hello, I'm new at Grafan and Prometheus. Prometheus is an open-source monitoring and alerting software that can collect metrics from different infrastructure and applications. But the real risk is when you create metrics with label values coming from the outside world. https://grafana.com/grafana/dashboards/2129. Before running this query, create a Pod with the following specification: If this query returns a positive value, then the cluster has overcommitted the CPU. Subscribe to receive notifications of new posts: Subscription confirmed. The difference with standard Prometheus starts when a new sample is about to be appended, but TSDB already stores the maximum number of time series its allowed to have. If we try to visualize how the perfect type of data Prometheus was designed for looks like well end up with this: A few continuous lines describing some observed properties. So there would be a chunk for: 00:00 - 01:59, 02:00 - 03:59, 04:00 - 05:59, , 22:00 - 23:59. For example, /api/v1/query?query=http_response_ok [24h]&time=t would return raw samples on the time range (t-24h . However when one of the expressions returns no data points found the result of the entire expression is no data points found.In my case there haven't been any failures so rio_dashorigin_serve_manifest_duration_millis_count{Success="Failed"} returns no data points found.Is there a way to write the query so that a . There is no equivalent functionality in a standard build of Prometheus, if any scrape produces some samples they will be appended to time series inside TSDB, creating new time series if needed. Finally getting back to this. Lets pick client_python for simplicity, but the same concepts will apply regardless of the language you use. To get rid of such time series Prometheus will run head garbage collection (remember that Head is the structure holding all memSeries) right after writing a block. What can a lawyer do if the client wants him to be acquitted of everything despite serious evidence? These flags are only exposed for testing and might have a negative impact on other parts of Prometheus server. In both nodes, edit the /etc/hosts file to add the private IP of the nodes. I believe it's the logic that it's written, but is there any conditions that can be used if there's no data recieved it returns a 0. what I tried doing is putting a condition or an absent function,but not sure if thats the correct approach. Internet-scale applications efficiently, Here are two examples of instant vectors: You can also use range vectors to select a particular time range. He has a Bachelor of Technology in Computer Science & Engineering from SRMS. What is the point of Thrower's Bandolier? Have a question about this project? A metric can be anything that you can express as a number, for example: To create metrics inside our application we can use one of many Prometheus client libraries. Redoing the align environment with a specific formatting. This might require Prometheus to create a new chunk if needed. Internally all time series are stored inside a map on a structure called Head. Has 90% of ice around Antarctica disappeared in less than a decade? Your needs or your customers' needs will evolve over time and so you cant just draw a line on how many bytes or cpu cycles it can consume. instance_memory_usage_bytes: This shows the current memory used. About an argument in Famine, Affluence and Morality. With 1,000 random requests we would end up with 1,000 time series in Prometheus. AFAIK it's not possible to hide them through Grafana. This article covered a lot of ground. All rights reserved. All chunks must be aligned to those two hour slots of wall clock time, so if TSDB was building a chunk for 10:00-11:59 and it was already full at 11:30 then it would create an extra chunk for the 11:30-11:59 time range. PROMQL: how to add values when there is no data returned? Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. By default Prometheus will create a chunk per each two hours of wall clock. I've been using comparison operators in Grafana for a long while. The problem is that the table is also showing reasons that happened 0 times in the time frame and I don't want to display them. Although you can tweak some of Prometheus' behavior and tweak it more for use with short lived time series, by passing one of the hidden flags, its generally discouraged to do so. Add field from calculation Binary operation. Extra metrics exported by Prometheus itself tell us if any scrape is exceeding the limit and if that happens we alert the team responsible for it. For that reason we do tolerate some percentage of short lived time series even if they are not a perfect fit for Prometheus and cost us more memory. Time arrow with "current position" evolving with overlay number. In our example case its a Counter class object. Prometheus simply counts how many samples are there in a scrape and if thats more than sample_limit allows it will fail the scrape. So I still can't use that metric in calculations ( e.g., success / (success + fail) ) as those calculations will return no datapoints. ***> wrote: You signed in with another tab or window. The below posts may be helpful for you to learn more about Kubernetes and our company. Run the following commands on the master node, only copy the kubeconfig and set up Flannel CNI. If both the nodes are running fine, you shouldnt get any result for this query. by (geo_region) < bool 4 If so it seems like this will skew the results of the query (e.g., quantiles). Thank you for subscribing! The TSDB limit patch protects the entire Prometheus from being overloaded by too many time series. When Prometheus sends an HTTP request to our application it will receive this response: This format and underlying data model are both covered extensively in Prometheus' own documentation. Youve learned about the main components of Prometheus, and its query language, PromQL. privacy statement. There is an open pull request which improves memory usage of labels by storing all labels as a single string. So the maximum number of time series we can end up creating is four (2*2). I was then able to perform a final sum by over the resulting series to reduce the results down to a single result, dropping the ad-hoc labels in the process. The actual amount of physical memory needed by Prometheus will usually be higher as a result, since it will include unused (garbage) memory that needs to be freed by Go runtime. In our example we have two labels, content and temperature, and both of them can have two different values. Since the default Prometheus scrape interval is one minute it would take two hours to reach 120 samples. Returns a list of label names. Now comes the fun stuff. Can airtags be tracked from an iMac desktop, with no iPhone? The more any application does for you, the more useful it is, the more resources it might need. Other Prometheus components include a data model that stores the metrics, client libraries for instrumenting code, and PromQL for querying the metrics. @rich-youngkin Yeah, what I originally meant with "exposing" a metric is whether it appears in your /metrics endpoint at all (for a given set of labels). This process is also aligned with the wall clock but shifted by one hour. We know that each time series will be kept in memory. entire corporate networks, And then there is Grafana, which comes with a lot of built-in dashboards for Kubernetes monitoring. Now we should pause to make an important distinction between metrics and time series. Name the nodes as Kubernetes Master and Kubernetes Worker. what does the Query Inspector show for the query you have a problem with? rev2023.3.3.43278. our free app that makes your Internet faster and safer. Do roots of these polynomials approach the negative of the Euler-Mascheroni constant? Here is the extract of the relevant options from Prometheus documentation: Setting all the label length related limits allows you to avoid a situation where extremely long label names or values end up taking too much memory. Prometheus and PromQL (Prometheus Query Language) are conceptually very simple, but this means that all the complexity is hidden in the interactions between different elements of the whole metrics pipeline. from and what youve done will help people to understand your problem. You can use these queries in the expression browser, Prometheus HTTP API, or visualization tools like Grafana. or Internet application, Please see data model and exposition format pages for more details. That response will have a list of, When Prometheus collects all the samples from our HTTP response it adds the timestamp of that collection and with all this information together we have a. By clicking Accept all cookies, you agree Stack Exchange can store cookies on your device and disclose information in accordance with our Cookie Policy. Explanation: Prometheus uses label matching in expressions. Run the following commands in both nodes to configure the Kubernetes repository. What can a lawyer do if the client wants him to be acquitted of everything despite serious evidence? This is an example of a nested subquery. Today, let's look a bit closer at the two ways of selecting data in PromQL: instant vector selectors and range vector selectors. These are the sane defaults that 99% of application exporting metrics would never exceed. Sign up and get Kubernetes tips delivered straight to your inbox. TSDB will try to estimate when a given chunk will reach 120 samples and it will set the maximum allowed time for current Head Chunk accordingly. The Head Chunk is never memory-mapped, its always stored in memory. ncdu: What's going on with this second size column? Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers, Reach developers & technologists worldwide, How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability. Every two hours Prometheus will persist chunks from memory onto the disk. I can't work out how to add the alerts to the deployments whilst retaining the deployments for which there were no alerts returned: If I use sum with or, then I get this, depending on the order of the arguments to or: If I reverse the order of the parameters to or, I get what I am after: But I'm stuck now if I want to do something like apply a weight to alerts of a different severity level, e.g. Prometheus - exclude 0 values from query result, How Intuit democratizes AI development across teams through reusability. That's the query (Counter metric): sum(increase(check_fail{app="monitor"}[20m])) by (reason). metric name, as measured over the last 5 minutes: Assuming that the http_requests_total time series all have the labels job This thread has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. This is one argument for not overusing labels, but often it cannot be avoided. So when TSDB is asked to append a new sample by any scrape, it will first check how many time series are already present. One Head Chunk - containing up to two hours of the last two hour wall clock slot. Of course there are many types of queries you can write, and other useful queries are freely available. Both rules will produce new metrics named after the value of the record field. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. To better handle problems with cardinality its best if we first get a better understanding of how Prometheus works and how time series consume memory. Once configured, your instances should be ready for access. This scenario is often described as cardinality explosion - some metric suddenly adds a huge number of distinct label values, creates a huge number of time series, causes Prometheus to run out of memory and you lose all observability as a result. If we configure a sample_limit of 100 and our metrics response contains 101 samples, then Prometheus wont scrape anything at all. You must define your metrics in your application, with names and labels that will allow you to work with resulting time series easily. Yeah, absent() is probably the way to go. When Prometheus collects metrics it records the time it started each collection and then it will use it to write timestamp & value pairs for each time series. The containers are named with a specific pattern: notification_checker [0-9] notification_sender [0-9] I need an alert when the number of container of the same pattern (eg. Prometheus does offer some options for dealing with high cardinality problems. This allows Prometheus to scrape and store thousands of samples per second, our biggest instances are appending 550k samples per second, while also allowing us to query all the metrics simultaneously. Labels are stored once per each memSeries instance. With any monitoring system its important that youre able to pull out the right data. At this point, both nodes should be ready. The nature of simulating nature: A Q&A with IBM Quantum researcher Dr. Jamie We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Staging Ground Beta 1 Recap, and Reviewers needed for Beta 2, Prometheus promQL query is not showing 0 when metric data does not exists, PromQL - how to get an interval between result values, PromQL delta for each elment in values array, Trigger alerts according to the environment in alertmanger, Prometheus alertmanager includes resolved alerts in a new alert. SSH into both servers and run the following commands to install Docker. The Linux Foundation has registered trademarks and uses trademarks. Or maybe we want to know if it was a cold drink or a hot one? (fanout by job name) and instance (fanout by instance of the job), we might I have a query that gets a pipeline builds and its divided by the number of change request open in a 1 month window, which gives a percentage. The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: This is correct. This helps Prometheus query data faster since all it needs to do is first locate the memSeries instance with labels matching our query and then find the chunks responsible for time range of the query. For example our errors_total metric, which we used in example before, might not be present at all until we start seeing some errors, and even then it might be just one or two errors that will be recorded. list, which does not convey images, so screenshots etc. This is the last line of defense for us that avoids the risk of the Prometheus server crashing due to lack of memory. Ive deliberately kept the setup simple and accessible from any address for demonstration. But before that, lets talk about the main components of Prometheus. Hmmm, upon further reflection, I'm wondering if this will throw the metrics off. The nature of simulating nature: A Q&A with IBM Quantum researcher Dr. Jamie We've added a "Necessary cookies only" option to the cookie consent popup. Another reason is that trying to stay on top of your usage can be a challenging task. 1 Like. It's worth to add that if using Grafana you should set 'Connect null values' proeprty to 'always' in order to get rid of blank spaces in the graph. It doesnt get easier than that, until you actually try to do it. Prometheus has gained a lot of market traction over the years, and when combined with other open-source tools like Grafana, it provides a robust monitoring solution. But I'm stuck now if I want to do something like apply a weight to alerts of a different severity level, e.g. Is a PhD visitor considered as a visiting scholar? I then hide the original query. I don't know how you tried to apply the comparison operators, but if I use this very similar query: I get a result of zero for all jobs that have not restarted over the past day and a non-zero result for jobs that have had instances restart. If instead of beverages we tracked the number of HTTP requests to a web server, and we used the request path as one of the label values, then anyone making a huge number of random requests could force our application to create a huge number of time series. This helps us avoid a situation where applications are exporting thousands of times series that arent really needed. You saw how PromQL basic expressions can return important metrics, which can be further processed with operators and functions. This is the modified flow with our patch: By running go_memstats_alloc_bytes / prometheus_tsdb_head_series query we know how much memory we need per single time series (on average), we also know how much physical memory we have available for Prometheus on each server, which means that we can easily calculate the rough number of time series we can store inside Prometheus, taking into account the fact the theres garbage collection overhead since Prometheus is written in Go: memory available to Prometheus / bytes per time series = our capacity. VictoriaMetrics has other advantages compared to Prometheus, ranging from massively parallel operation for scalability, better performance, and better data compression, though what we focus on for this blog post is a rate () function handling.

Lexington, Ky Obituaries, Articles P

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail